| Paul J. Achtemeier | Biblical Studies Religion, Rhetoric and Composition Language | | | | |
| Stuart G. Baskin | Theology, History Economics, History of Religion | | | 2002 | Douglas F. Ottati (grad student) |
| Matthew D. Bates | Theology | | | 2005 | Charles M. Swezey (grad student) |
| Timothy T. Boddie | Religious Education, Black History, History of Religion, Black Studies | | | 2003 | Jane R. Vann (grad student) |
| Eugene H. Breitenberg | Theology, General Religion, Religious Education | | | 2004 | Douglas F. Ottati (grad student) |
| Aubrey L. Brooks | Biblical Studies Religion | | | | |
| Florence E. Canada | Religious Education, General Religion, Church History, Black Studies | | | 2004 | Jane R. Vann (grad student) |
| Maggie S. Choo | Biblical Studies Religion, Linguistics Language, Women's Studies, Theology | | | 2009 | Andreas K. Schuele (grad student) |
| Dawn DeVries | Theology | | | | |
| Daniel J. Earheart-Brown | Theology | | | 2000 | Dawn DeVries (grad student) |
| Jennifer Garvin-Sanchez | Theology, General | | | 2006 | Douglas F. Ottati (grad student) |
| Frances T. Gench | Biblical Studies Religion | | | | |
| Brian Albert Gerrish | | | | | |
| Tracy L. Hartman | Theology, Women's Studies, Clergy Religion | | | 2001 | Beverly Zink-Sawyer (grad student) |
| Elizabeth L. Hinson-Hasty | Theology, Women's Studies | | | 2002 | Douglas F. Ottati (grad student) |
| Mary K. Hohmann | Religious Education, Early Childhood Education | | | 2003 | Pamela M. Legg (grad student) |
| Brenda M. Hurst | History of Religion, Church History, United States History, Women's Studies | | | 2003 | Mark Valeri (grad student) |
| Inock Kim | Religious Education | | | 2005 | Jane R. Vann (grad student) |
| Jack D. Kingsbury | Biblical Studies Religion, Classical Literature | | | | |
| Sheila A. Klassen-Wiebe | Biblical Studies Religion | | | 2001 | Jack D. Kingsbury (grad student) |
| Gun H. Lee | Theology, Church History, History of Religion | | | 2003 | Stan Skreslet (grad student) |
| Pamela M. Legg | Religious Education, Theology, Curriculum and Instruction Education | | | | |
| Patricia A. MacNicoll | Biblical Studies Religion | | | 2002 | W Sibley Towner (grad student) |
| William H. Malas | Biblical Studies Religion, Classical Literature | | | 2001 | Jack D. Kingsbury (grad student) |
| Richard E. Oppong | Curriculum and Instruction Education, Religious Education | | | 2000 | Pamela M. Legg (grad student) |
| Douglas F. Ottati | Theology | | | | |
| Sang-Jin Park | Religious Education, Theology, Curriculum and Instruction Education | | | 2001 | Pamela M. Legg (grad student) |
| Shelly B. Parsons | Religious Education, Biblical Studies Religion, Women's Studies | | | 2005 | Pamela M. Legg (grad student) |
| Chad Quaintance | History of Religion | | | 2003 | Dawn DeVries (grad student) |
| Andreas K. Schuele | Biblical Studies Religion, Linguistics Language, Women's Studies, Theology | | | | |
| Stan Skreslet | Theology, Church History, History of Religion | | | | |
| Charles M. Swezey | Theology | | | | |
| Carmel Tinnes | Religious Education, Fine Arts, General Religion | | | 2003 | Pamela M. Legg (grad student) |
| David J. Torbett | Theology, Church History, Black History | | | 2002 | Mark Valeri (grad student) |
| W Sibley Towner | Biblical Studies Religion | | | | |
| David B. True | Theology, General Religion, General | | | 2005 | Douglas F. Ottati (grad student) |
| Mark Valeri | Theology, Church History, Black History | | | | |
| Jane R. Vann | Religious Education, Black History, History of Religion, Black Studies | | | | |
| Michael E. Vines | Biblical Studies Religion, Classical Literature | | | 2001 | Jack D. Kingsbury (grad student) |
| Eric M. Wallace | Biblical Studies Religion | | | 2004 | Frances T. Gench (grad student) |
| Karen-Marie Yust | Religious Education, Technology of Education, General Religion | | | | |
| Beverly Zink-Sawyer | Theology, Women's Studies, Clergy Religion | | | | |